In the tumultuous, often self-serious landscape of modern rock, there exist bands that not only defy categorization but actively relish in their own glorious chaos. Toronto’s punk rock savants, PUP, are unequivocally one such band. With their sophomore full-length offering, The Dream Is Over, they cemented their reputation as purveyors of cathartic, intelligent, and relentlessly energetic anthems. However, it is with their imagined follow-up, Who Will Look After The Dogs, that PUP truly unleashes their full, unbridled potential, delivering an album that is nothing short of a masterclass in controlled pandemonium, poignant self-reflection, and undeniably infectious songwriting. This isn’t just a collection of songs; it’s a vibrant, visceral journey through the anxieties, absurdities, and undeniable camaraderie of growing up and staying together in a world that constantly threatens to tear you apart. Who Will Look After The Dogs is, without a doubt, a resounding triumph for PUP, a testament to their unwavering vision, their blistering musicianship, and their unique ability to transform raw, unvarnished emotion into exhilarating sonic art.
From the very first discordant chord, the album grabs you by the collar and doesn’t let go. The opening track, “Leash Laws & Lifelines,” bursts forth with an immediate, almost frantic energy that is characteristic of PUP’s best work. Stefan Babcock’s signature strained-yet-melodic vocals are upfront, delivering biting, witty lyrics about loyalty, abandonment, and the precarious balance of keeping things together. The twin guitar attack of Babcock and Steve Sladkowski is sharp, precise, and gloriously abrasive, while Nestor Chumak’s basslines are a relentless, driving force, and Zack Mykula’s drumming is a whirlwind of intricate fills and powerhouse beats. It’s a sonic assault in the best possible way, establishing the album’s ferocious intensity and lyrical depth right from the outset. This immediately transitions into “Feral Heart,” a track that might temper the initial fury with a more melodic, yet equally potent, exploration of inner wildness and the struggle for domestication. The chorus, instantly memorable and singalong-ready, showcases PUP’s knack for crafting hooks that burrow deep into your brain.
What truly elevates Who Will Look After The Dogs is the band’s remarkable ability to inject profound thematic weight into their high-octane delivery. Stefan Babcock remains one of the most compelling lyricists in contemporary punk. His words are a brilliant tapestry of self-deprecation, observational humor, genuine vulnerability, and searing social commentary. He tackles the anxieties of commitment, the dread of adulthood, the fear of losing your friends, and the existential malaise of trying to find meaning in a chaotic world. Yet, even in the darkest corners of his introspection, there’s an underlying thread of resilience and a defiant joy in the shared struggle. On a track like “Collarbone Blues,” he might explore the physical and emotional toll of relentless touring and the sacrifices made for their art, delivering lines with a weary honesty that resonates deeply. This isn’t just angst for angst’s sake; it’s a meticulously articulated exploration of modern ennui, delivered with a wry smirk and a clenched fist.
The musical prowess of PUP is undeniable. Steve Sladkowski’s guitar work is particularly noteworthy, weaving intricate melodies and scorching riffs through the propulsive rhythm section. He knows exactly when to unleash a torrent of feedback and when to step back, allowing Babcock’s vocals to take center stage. Nestor Chumak’s bass is far more than just a foundation; it’s a dynamic, melodic instrument that often carries significant weight in the band’s arrangements, providing counter-melodies and driving momentum. And Zack Mykula’s drumming is simply breathtaking – powerful, inventive, and seemingly boundless in its energy. His fills are legendary, his tempo unwavering, and his ability to navigate complex rhythms while maintaining punk rock ferocity is a marvel. The synergy between these four musicians is what makes PUP such a formidable force; they play with an instinctive understanding of each other, creating a sound that is both tightly controlled and gloriously unhinged. The production on Who Will Look After The Dogs is perfectly calibrated, raw enough to retain the band’s live energy but polished enough to allow every intricate detail to shine through.
One of the album’s emotional anchors is “The Stray’s Soliloquy,” a slower, more introspective track that allows Babcock’s voice to take on a more vulnerable, almost whispered quality before building to a powerful, cathartic scream. This song explores themes of belonging, the feeling of being an outcast, and the desperate search for connection. The dynamic shifts are masterfully handled, showcasing the band’s versatility beyond their usual full-throttle assault. Similarly, “Housebroken Hearts” might delve into the fear of domesticity and the struggle to maintain one’s wild spirit within the confines of a relationship or societal expectations. These moments of introspection provide crucial breathing room within the album’s otherwise relentless pace, highlighting the emotional depth that underpins their noisy exterior.
The album is also laced with PUP’s characteristic gallows humor and playful absurdity. Tracks like “Chew Toys & Crushed Dreams” likely use dog-related metaphors to unpack the absurdities of life, friendships, and the music industry itself, all delivered with a knowing wink and a healthy dose of cynicism. This self-awareness prevents the album from ever feeling overly earnest or self-pitying. Instead, it transforms personal anxieties into universally relatable anthems of shared neuroses, inviting listeners to laugh along with their pain. The gang vocals, a staple of PUP’s sound, are more prominent and rousing than ever, creating an undeniable sense of communal release that is infectious. These are songs meant to be screamed back at the band in a sweaty club, a collective exhalation of all the frustrations and joys of being alive.
Thematic cohesion is a strong suit of Who Will Look After The Dogs. The metaphors of dogs, loyalty, wildness, and domestication are expertly woven throughout the album, providing a compelling narrative thread without ever feeling heavy-handed or contrived. It’s a clever conceit that allows Babcock to explore a wide range of human emotions and experiences through a unique, often darkly comedic lens. The album flows with an organic momentum, each track leading seamlessly into the next, building a complete, immersive world for the listener. Even with the raw energy, there’s a clear sense of purpose and direction, showcasing a band that has refined their craft and knows exactly what they want to say, and how they want to say it.
Who Will Look After The Dogs also sees PUP expanding their sonic palette in subtle yet significant ways. While the core of their sound remains rooted in aggressive, melodic punk, there are moments where they incorporate more intricate guitar harmonies, unexpected tempo changes, or even touches of melodic complexity that hint at their broader musical influences. This evolution ensures that the album feels fresh and exciting, never resting on their laurels or simply rehashing past successes. It’s the sound of a band confidently pushing their own boundaries, eager to explore new sonic territories while remaining true to their distinctive identity. This willingness to experiment, while never losing their core ferocity, is a mark of true artistic growth.
In conclusion, Who Will Look After The Dogs is an absolute triumph for PUP, a blistering, brilliant, and emotionally resonant album that cements their place as one of the most exciting and vital bands in contemporary rock. It’s an album that perfectly balances chaotic energy with profound introspection, witty lyricism with raw vulnerability, and relentless intensity with undeniable melodicism. Stefan Babcock’s songwriting is at its most potent, his lyrics sharp, insightful, and profoundly relatable, while the band’s collective musicianship is nothing short of extraordinary. From the exhilarating opener to the contemplative, yet still defiant, closer, every track on Who Will Look After The Dogs is a testament to PUP’s singular vision and their unwavering dedication to their craft. This album is a joyous, cathartic roar against the anxieties of modern life, an anthem for anyone who’s ever felt lost, angry, or just plain fed up, but still finds solace and strength in shared experience. Dive into Who Will Look After The Dogs; it will bite, it will scratch, and it will leave an indelible mark on your soul.
This post has already been read 3 times!
